Cognitive Behavior Therapy for Depression from an Evolutionary Perspective: Key Takeaways and Implications

Morgan Hagner, PsyD, Post-Doctoral Fellow, Beck Institute for Cognitive Behavior Therapy

The article “Cognitive Behavior Therapy for Depression From an Evolutionary Perspective” by Steven D. Hollon, Paul W. Andrews, and J. Anderson Thomson Jr., delves into the intersection of evolutionary medicine and Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) for depression. The authors present an evolutionary viewpoint of how depression, often seen as a disorder, might actually be an evolved adaptation with specific functions that increased our ancestors’ survival and reproductive success. The following highlights the article’s main takeaways, clinical implications, and considerations for integrating evolutionary perspectives into contemporary CBT.

Evolutionary Medicine Context

The authors begin by situating their discussion within the broader field of evolutionary medicine, which differentiates between diseased states and healthy responses to disease states. For instance, fever and diarrhea are not diseases themselves but evolved adaptations that help the body combat infections. This perspective frames depression as an adaptive response to certain environmental and social challenges. Furthermore, this distinction makes the case for viewing non-psychotic disorders on a continuum of “normal to pathological states” using frequency, intensity, and impairment as markers for function and pathology. Looking at the examples of fever and diarrhea, too much of such reactions can be problematic and potentially lethal, but a less pronounced response could ultimately improve chances of survival and well-being.

Depression as an Adaptation

Anxiety has often been discussed in this context. Anxiety triggers a “fight or flight” response which prepares the body to respond to potential threats. One of the central arguments of the article is that non-psychotic disorders, like depression and anxiety, are more likely to be adaptations, not diseases. These conditions may have evolved to serve specific functions that enhanced inclusive fitness in our ancestral environment. This evolutionary adaptation helped our ancestors confront or flee from predators and ultimately survive in dangerous environments.

Role of Rumination

A key aspect of this evolutionary perspective is the role of rumination. The authors propose that depression may have evolved to facilitate a deliberate and analytical cognitive style (rumination) in response to complex social issues. Rumination, although often seen as a pathological symptom, may sometimes serve a functional purpose by allowing individuals to focus intensely on resolving intricate social problems. This idea has significant implications for treatment, suggesting that strength-based interventions that support the adaptability of this cognitive process might be more effective than those that merely aim to stop it.

CBT Mechanisms

Additionally, the article explores how CBT can align with the evolutionary functions of depression. CBT helps individuals identify and evaluate the helpfulness of thought patterns and behaviors, and ultimately, develop skills that could replace the unhelpful strategies. From an evolutionary perspective, CBT can facilitate the functions that depression evolved to serve. For instance, CBT can help individuals develop more adaptive and flexible ways of thinking and problem-solving, which aligns with the idea that depression evolved to help people deal with complex social challenges. In doing so, CBT utilizes both problem-based and strength-based approaches to evaluate the function of cognitive and behavioral processes and teach adaptive strategies that can improve overall functioning.

Implications for Treatment

Understanding depression from an evolutionary perspective has profound implications for treatment. It suggests that rather than viewing depression solely as a disorder to be eradicated, therapists might consider how to harness its adaptive functions. This approach could lead to more effective interventions that not only alleviate symptoms but also support the underlying cognitive processes that depression might facilitate. For example, CBT techniques that encourage constructive rumination and problem-solving could be particularly beneficial. In this way, CBT therapists can help clients address the underlying issues that contribute to their depressive symptoms and empower them to develop more adaptive coping strategies.

Additionally, the evolutionary perspective highlights the importance of individualized treatment. Since depression may serve different functions for different individuals, a one-size-fits-all approach may not be effective. Clinicians can use this understanding to tailor interventions to the specific needs and contexts of their clients. For example, some clients may benefit more from interventions that focus on enhancing social problem-solving skills, while others may need support in managing the physiological aspects of depressive responses. Integrating CBT with an evolutionary understanding of depression can provide a more comprehensive and effective treatment approach that addresses both the symptoms and the underlying functions of the condition.

Finally, this viewpoint could reduce the stigma associated with depression, as it normalizes the condition and recognizes the potential benefits, rather than focusing solely on the dysfunctional properties of rumination. A shift in perception could improve client engagement and adherence to treatment, as individuals may feel more understood and validated in their experiences. Clients might also learn flexibility in their thinking and potentially recognize that there is a continuum of usefulness in their responses, all of which may not necessarily fit in an all-or-nothing or good-or-bad framework.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the article “Cognitive Behavior Therapy for Depression from an Evolutionary Perspective” offers a thought-provoking re-evaluation of depression and its treatment. By framing depression as a potential adaptation rather than a disorder, clinicians are offered different avenues for understanding and treating this condition. This evolutionary lens highlights the importance of considering the functional aspects of depression and taking a strength-based perspective in treatment. Consequently, therapeutic approaches like CBT can be tailored to support the adaptive functions of client thoughts and behaviors rather than simply alleviating symptoms. This shift in focus can lead to more effective and sustainable treatment outcomes, encourage a more nuanced understanding of depression, and promote individualized and holistic case conceptualizations.

---

Reference

Hollon, S. D., Andrews, P. W., & Thomson Jr, J. A. (2021). Cognitive behavior therapy for depression from an evolutionary perspective. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 12, 667592.